Station 1 of 12 · Day 1 of 14
Justice
Is justice real, or just the interest of the stronger?
Justice is the order that lets unequal claims live together — render to each what each is due.
Before justice is a virtue of persons it is a problem of the city: when your good and mine collide, by what measure do we settle it? Thrasymachus answers cynically — justice is whatever serves the strong. Plato spends the rest of the Republic refusing that answer, arguing that justice is a harmony, in the soul and in the state, where each part does its own work and none usurps another's.
It opens the conversation that runs through Aristotle's fairness, the social-contract thinkers, and every modern argument about rights and the common good.
In the reader’s own words
I proclaim that justice is nothing else than the interest of the stronger.Plato, Republic, Book I (Thrasymachus), 338c — trans. Jowett
Ask Virgil
Take a position
Thrasymachus says justice is nothing but the interest of the stronger. Before you dismiss it — where have you actually seen that be true? And does admitting it force you to give up on justice?