Station 1 of 12 · Day 1 of 14

Justice

Is justice real, or just the interest of the stronger?

Justice is the order that lets unequal claims live together — render to each what each is due.

Before justice is a virtue of persons it is a problem of the city: when your good and mine collide, by what measure do we settle it? Thrasymachus answers cynically — justice is whatever serves the strong. Plato spends the rest of the Republic refusing that answer, arguing that justice is a harmony, in the soul and in the state, where each part does its own work and none usurps another's.

It opens the conversation that runs through Aristotle's fairness, the social-contract thinkers, and every modern argument about rights and the common good.

Thrasymachus

In the reader’s own words

I proclaim that justice is nothing else than the interest of the stronger.Plato, Republic, Book I (Thrasymachus), 338c — trans. Jowett

Ask Virgil


Take a position

Thrasymachus says justice is nothing but the interest of the stronger. Before you dismiss it — where have you actually seen that be true? And does admitting it force you to give up on justice?


The thinkers who fought over it

Lecture

Where this meets your life

Dive deeper